by John McCarthy Consulting Ltd. | Mar 10, 2023 | News
As part of the new ISQM 1 audit quality management standard, there has been much commentary about a new procedure called Root Cause Analysis or RCA.
Root cause analysis is now a compulsory requirement of audit quality control under paragraph 41 of the ISQM. It focuses on understanding the underlying cause behind the deficiencies identified on audit files and in audit quality processes to help provide valuable insights to the firm and help with remedial action.
It’s not practical to apply RCA to every deficiency. Firms will need to design a way of appropriately targeting RCA at the most appropriate reviews and findings.
The selection of deficiencies on which to focus RCA will involve taking the following factors into account:
- The quantum/frequency of the audit risk and/or whether the audit is high profile;
- The reviews it could be applied to, cold file reviews, engagement quality reviews and/or external monitoring reviews;
- The possible selection of all low scoring/graded files, in cold file reviews; and
- Whether the findings in question are recurring themes.
Please go to our website to see our new ISQM TOOLKIT or if you prefer to chat through the different audit risks and potential appropriate responses presented by this new standard, please contact John McCarthy FCA by e-mail at john@jmcc.ie.
We typically tailor training and brainstorming sessions to suit your firm’s unique requirements.
Publications and AML webinars:
- The ISQM TOOLKIT 2022 is available to purchase here.
- See our latest Anti-Money Laundering Policies Controls & Procedures Manual (March 2022) – View the Table of Contents click here.
- Also we have an updated AML webinar (March 2022) available here, which accompanies the AML Manual. It explains the current legal AML reporting position for accountancy firms and includes a quiz. Upon completion, you receive a CPD Certificate of attendance in your inbox.
- To ensure your letters of engagement and similar templates are up to date visit our site here where immediate downloads are available in Word format. A bulk discount is available for orders of five or more items if bought together.
by John McCarthy Consulting Ltd. | Jun 18, 2026 | Blog, News
The ISQM 1 regime is now fully in place since its initial roll out in 2021. Every Irish audit firm will need an ISQM-compliant System of Quality Management (‘SOQM’).
Many firms have already prepared their ISQM 1 policy statement (called the Statement of Quality Management or SoQM), but have you reviewed yours in accordance with the standard on an annual basis since its initial implementation.
Our ISQM TOOLKIT is the answer to your needs and is available to purchase now for immediate download to help you. Click here for more details.
Regulators are looking for clear evidence of progress with the application of the standard and especially with evidence of root cause analysis (RCA).
Here are our top ten tips to helping you get your SOQM across the finish line:
- Read the ISQM. There’s really no way around this!
We’d recommend you also get hold of the IAASM Implementation Guide, which is genuinely helpful – although be warned; this is for the international version of the ISQM and doesn’t include the additional quality responses added to the Irish standard by the Irish Audit & Accounting Supervisory Authority (IAASA).
- Assess your current approach to audit quality. Firms have various audit quality policies and procedures already in place. While we want to stress that you shouldn’t simply ‘bolt on’ ISQM to your existing approach, it’s helpful to get a clear insight into what’s happening now (e.g., by taking a look with a critical eye at your existing procedures and matching them to the requirements of our ISQM Toolkit).
This may mean gathering various documents (like staff appraisals, CPD plans and IES 8), clarifying existing arrangements with the rest of the audit team and organising your thoughts.
- Find out what your team thinks about your current approach. Chances are, you and your team already have sound insights into what’s working well and what isn’t, and some honest feedback may be painful but is essential to making progress.
John McCarthy Consulting Ltd. (working in conjunction with our colleagues in Apex Professional Consulting Ltd.) has produced the ISQM TOOLKIT for the Republic of Ireland. It comes with a unique team questionnaire that can help you to gather anonymous feedback including suggestions for tackling problem areas.
- Start with leadership and governance issues. For most if not all small firms, a critical success factor for ISQM compliance is the degree of support from partners, especially managing partners within firms.
Whether your firm is a sole practitioner or a larger firm, ISQM 1 challenges senior leadership to demonstrate genuine commitment to audit quality, recognising that this may not always align with a firm’s commercial strategy or its leaders’ priorities. You need to identify and deal with those conflicts, if present. You’ll also need to consider how much of the SOQM can be delegated to others and how the firm’s leadership will demonstrate that they bear ultimate responsibility for its success.
5. Don’t dismiss the appointment stage. Many firms assign consideration of (re)appointment to junior audit staff who lack the judgement to assess ethical threats and to apply the right safeguards. Accepting a client relationship or engagement inappropriately removes any chance to achieve a quality audit.
6. Be honest about priorities. Many firms say that they’re committed to audit quality, but a cursory scrutiny about how much of the firm’s time and money is spent in supporting and developing high quality audit may suggest otherwise. ISQM 1 demands that firms allocate enough resource to recruit and develop audit teams, supply them with appropriate tools (including hardware and software) and allow them the time to conduct audits thoroughly. You’ll also need to assess the quality risks of over-relying on external training providers, file reviewers or providers of methodology or IT tools.
7. Refocus on prevention rather than cure. In the past, many audit firms have relied on regular cold file reviews to ensure their quality is up to scratch. Whilst such reviews will still play a key role, firms need to consider how to avoid audit defects altogether. For many audit partners, this may mean reducing the amount of time spent in review, and increasing the time spent in directing and supervising audits whilst in progress. Better prepared and managed teams should produce better audit files that need less review and remediation.
8. Plan your monitoring as you go. As you set out your SOQM, make sure that every element is trackable and assign responsibility for monitoring to specific individuals, with clear instructions about how they should check progress and how they must record this. This should make the ‘monitoring and remediation’ part of the process much less burdensome. Don’t leave it all until the end!
9. Get familiar with Root Cause Analysis (‘RCA’). This is a tool that has increased in profile of late, and while RCA can be sophisticated, it needn’t always be so. The aim is to identify systemic defects that, if corrected, will prevent problems from recurring. Don’t be afraid of asking ‘why did X happen’ multiple times when a quality problem is spotted, until the roots are uncovered.
10. Consider external support. Whilst it’s possible to implement ISQM 1 without any other support, especially if you use a good transition tool you may find that getting the assistance of a specialist can be hugely valuable, even if just as a sounding board.
If you need assistance with implementation, or have any questions please contact John by e-mail john@jmcc.ie.
The ISQM TOOLKIT is available here to purchase now for immediate download.
All the templates on our website have had a refresh as of June 2026 and the letters of engagement have had new paragraphs added for:
- the potential use of artificial intelligence and machine learning on client assignments;
- along with auto enrolment for payroll assignments.
There is a bulk discount (five templates for the price of four) for purchases of five or more templates when purchased in a single transaction.
If you need an up-to-date engagement letter, there is a search bar near the bottom of our home page (www.jmcc.ie) to quickly look up the item you need. More details see here.
For those of you still in the process of ISQM 1 implementation, please see our ISQM TOOLKIT or if you prefer to chat through the different audit risks and potential appropriate responses presented by this new standard, please call or e-mail John McCarthy FCA or e-mail him at john@jmcc.ie.
We typically tailor our training and brainstorming sessions to suit each firm’s unique requirements.
Publications:
All the templates on our website have had a refresh as of June 2026 and the letters of engagement have had new paragraphs added for:
- the potential use of artificial intelligence and machine learning on client assignments;
- along with auto enrolment for payroll assignments.
There is a bulk discount (five templates for the price of four) for purchases of five or more templates when purchased in a single transaction.
If you need an up-to-date engagement letter, there is a search bar near the bottom of our home page (www.jmcc.ie) to quickly look up the item you need. More details see here.
For those of you still in the process of reviewing your ISQM 1 implementation, please see our ISQM TOOLKIT or if you prefer to chat through the different audit risks and potential appropriate responses presented by this new standard, please call or e-mail John McCarthy FCA or e-mail him at john@jmcc.ie.
We typically tailor our training and brainstorming sessions to suit each firm’s unique requirements.
Publications:
by John McCarthy Consulting Ltd. | Feb 22, 2026 | Blog, News
The International Standard on Quality Management (ISQM) 1 has now been in place since 15 December 2022. Have you reviewed your ISQM in action and updated it for any root cause analysis carried out in the interim?
The standard requires firms to record quality objectives in six key areas. These are:
- Governance and leadership;
- Relevant ethical requirements;
- Acceptance and continuance of client relationships and specific engagements;
- Engagement performance;
- Resources; and
- Information and communication.
The first of these areas is Governance and leadership. This is of paramount importance to quality management because it drives how the firm is perceived by its Partner, staff, audit clients and ultimately the public. Governance and leadership principles serve as the framework for how the firm’s decisions are made.
The standard has enhanced requirements regarding the firm’s commitment to quality through its culture.
4 Key Areas of Quality
The requirements now also focus on 4 key areas:
- The firm’s public interest role;
- The importance of professional ethics, values and attitudes;
- The responsibility of all personnel for quality relating to the performance of engagements or activities within the Statement of Quality Management (SoQM), and their expected behaviour; and
- Quality in the context of the firm’s strategic decisions and actions (e.g. will we expand the Tax Department and offer tax planning services to our private company audit clients?), including the firm’s financial and operational priorities.
There are requirements that:
- Address leadership’s behaviour and commitment to quality, and their accountability for quality;
- Address the organizational structure of the firm and the firm’s assignment of roles, responsibilities and authority; and
- Address resource needs, and resource planning, allocation and assignment, which also include financial resources for matters like up-to-date software and training.
This brief blog is only a summary of the main requirements.
For more assistance please see our ISQM Toolkit or if you prefer to chat through the different audit risks and potential appropriate responses presented by this standard, please call or e-mail John McCarthy FCA on Governance and leadership or e-mail him at john@jmcc.ie
Other publications and AML webinar
by John McCarthy Consulting Ltd. | Jun 18, 2024 | Blog, News
Following on from last week’s blog on cold file reviews and ISQM 1, this week we look at the various factors that can cause changes to the monitoring and remediation elements of ISQM 1.
The following variables are usually areas that need updated:
- The quality objectives set out in the system of quality management (SoQM);
- The quality risks of their assessments; and
- The responses to those risks.
Changes in these areas are mainly a result of:
- Changes in the nature and circumstances of the firm and its engagements; and
- Remedial actions to address deficiencies in the system of quality management.
These changes can arise in a variety of ways, such as:
- Changes to quality objectives;
- A need for new additional quality objectives g. if the firm opens a new office, merges with another firm or starts providing a new service;
- Additional quality objectives established by the firm may no longer be needed, or may need to be modified; and
- Root cause analysis (RCA) may identify that previous attempts at fixing issues from past cold file reviews are no longer be needed, need to be modified, or require a new solution.
Remember that the Specified Responses prescribed by the standard (detailed here in paragraph 34) must not be modified or removed, unless one or more of them is no longer relevant to the firm. The firm may decide that it’s appropriate to modify how these Specified Responses are designed and implemented.
The types of changes that can be triggered by the cold file review process broadly fall into two categories:
- Changes to quality risks such as:
- New quality risks are identified;
- Existing quality risks no longer qualify as quality risks;
- Existing quality risks need to be modified; and
- Existing quality risks need to be reassessed.
- Changes to responses to quality risks such as:
- New responses may be designed and put into action;
- Existing responses may be discontinued and deemed no longer appropriate; and
- Existing responses may need to be adjusted for changes in circumstances such as a new audit programme.
For more on the whole ISQM process please see our ISQM 1 Toolkit on our website here.
Please go to our website to see our:
- Anti-Money Laundering Policies Controls and Procedures Manual (March 2022) — View the table of contents
- AML Webinar (December 2023) available here, which accompanies the AML Manual. It explains the latest legal AML reporting position for accountancy firms and includes a quiz. Upon completion you receive a CPD certificate for attendance in your inbox.
- Letters of engagement and similar templates—Please visit our website here where immediate downloads are available in Word format. A bulk discount is available for orders of five or more items bought together.
- ISQM TOOLKIT, or if you prefer to chat through the different audit risks and potential appropriate responses presented by this new standard, please contact John McCarthy FCA by email at john@jmcc.ie.
- We typically tailor ISQM training and brainstorming sessions to suit your firm’s unique requirements. The ISQM TOOLKIT 2022 is available to purchase here.
by John McCarthy Consulting Ltd. | Jan 14, 2024 | Blog, News
The International Standards on Quality Management (ISQM) has been effective since December 2022.
It is applicable to all audit firms and is a step-change from the requirements of the, now defunct, ISQC 1. The ISQM introduced:
- a new risk-based quality management approach that requires audit firms to
- design and implement a System of Quality Management (SoQM); and
- operate that system of quality management for audits, reviews of financial statements or other assurance engagements.
Now that the standard has been in effect for just over 12 months, each firm must compulsorily carry out a documented review of their System of Quality Management to assess its effectiveness since coming into force in December 2022.
Part of this assessment before the 2024 audit season commences, will be:
- documenting the results of hot and cold file reviews that took place during 2023;
- analyse the root causes of these findings; and
- extract from these issues the reasons why the more significant/most frequent findings arose;
- decide as a firm how best to avoid repeating the same mistakes; and
- adjust the SoQM accordingly for a more effective audit approach in 2024.
Anyone who may like to migrate to a very user friendly version of the ISQM or use it as a benchmarking tool against which to measure the effectiveness of your current ISQM, may purchase our ISQM Toolkit for €250+VAT here.
Key features:
The Toolkit comprises three parts that are downloadable in Word format, with associated instructions in pdf format.
Part 1 – Setting Objectives and Risks.
Part 2 – Risk Assessment and Responses.
Part 3 – Monitoring and Remediation including Root Cause Analysis (RCA).
The toolkit comes with three additional optional questionnaires to help with documenting an assessment of the firm’s:
- Methodology and software providers;
- Training providers; and
- File review and Technical Queries consultants.
More information on the ISQM Toolkit is available here.
In addition, during 2023 we also published a very helpful IT Controls Assessment questionnaire tool for audit firms to help implement ISA 315.
IT Controls Assessment
Auditors are reminded that there are relatively significant changes in the requirements of ISA 315 Identifying and Assessing the Risks of Material Misstatement which was first applicable for accounting Periods Ended 21 December 2022 and of course Periods Ended 21 December 2023.
Auditors dealing with audits of affected entities will already have adopted new audit programmes in 2023, in additional to the normal audit tests, will also need to assess the entity’s IT controls (no matter what the size of that entity).
This is a significant new development for auditors of SMEs, in particular, and will be a game changer ion the type of audit documentation and evidence of assessment of such IT controls by the auditor on audit files.
For an easy to implement additional (two page) IT Controls Questionnaire to help document the above process, please click on this link to download immediately for only €60 + VAT.
Please also go to our website www.jmcc.ie/training to see our latest:
- Latest updated AML for Accountants webinar (December 2023) which explains the current legal AML reporting position for accountancy firms and includes a quiz. Upon completion, you receive a CPD Certificate of attendance in your inbox. A 20% discount is available for orders of five or more webinars/products, if bought together.
- There are other accounting/audit webinars on the site and more will follow throughout 2024.
- Anti-Money Laundering Policies Controls & Procedures Manual (March 2022) – View the Table of Contents click here.
- letters of engagement and similar templates. Please visit our site here where immediate downloads are available in Word format. A bulk discount is available for orders of five or more items if bought together.
- ISQM TOOLKIT – We can also tailor ISQM training and brainstorming sessions to suit your firm’s unique requirements. The ISQM TOOLKIT 2022 is available to purchase here.